How to Pick the Perfect Baby Carrier (And Avoid Common Mistakes)

This is not rocket science - but it is something that too often goes wrong. As a certified babywearing consultant teaching parents for over 8 years, I’ve seen firsthand how overwhelmed people are by the endless choices, marketing jargon and misinformation. The result? Far too many end up buying the wrong carrier - and that has a real impact. Whether it’s mom or dad, the wrong fit makes babywearing unsafe, uncomfortable or simply unappealing. So if you're thinking about getting a new carrier, read to the end - it may be the best time investment you make.

1. Stretchy Wraps

Long pieces of elastic fabric, typically soft jersey cotton, wrapped snugly around you and your baby.

Pros:

Ideal for newborns; potential to provide a womb-like feel and great support for parent and baby in first months.

Budget-friendly.

Soft and cozy for early bonding.

Cons:

Can feel overwhelming or complicated to use.

Less supportive for older or heavier babies.

Bulky and may require frequent adjustments.

Best for: Parents seeking a soft, snug option for the early months - and who don’t mind a bit of practice.

2. Woven Wraps

Made from strong, non-stretchy fabric like cotton, linen, or blends. Tied in specific ways for different carries.

Pros:

Extremely versatile; supports front, hip, and back carries.

Excellent weight distribution and long-term durability.

Suitable for babies and toddlers alike.

Cons:

Steep learning curve; takes time to master.

Can be time-consuming to wrap.

Best for: Parents willing to invest time in a long-lasting, adaptable carrier. A good quality woven wrap will last forever.

3. Ring Slings

A length of fabric threaded through two rings to create a pouch for your baby. Worn over one shoulder.

Pros:

Quick to put on and take off.

Great for short trips or on-the-go nursing.

Cons:

Weight is carried on one shoulder, which can cause discomfort.

Back carry is possible but not common. Mostly used for a front and hip carries.

Requires some practice to adjust correctly and use safely hands-free.

Best for: Parents needing a quick, compact carrier for short outings or nursing.

4. Mei Tais, Onbuhimos

Traditional, strap-based carriers with or without waistbands, inspired by East Asian designs.

Pros:

Lightweight and breathable - great for warmer weather.

Adjustable and suitable for various carries (front, hip, back).

A more intuitive step between wraps and buckled carriers.  

Cons:

If tying is involved, require learning basic tying techniques.

Not as fast to use as fully buckled options.

Best for:  Parents looking for a simple, structured alternative with the flexibility of a wrap.

5. Buckled Carriers (Soft Structured Carriers)

These carriers come with padded straps and waistbands plus adjustable buckles for a pre-shaped secure fit.

Pros:

Easy to use - no wrapping or tying required + Comfortable for longer periods, thanks to padded shoulder and waist support.

Great for heavier babies and back carries - especially useful into toddlerhood.

Cons:

Can be bulky and less breathable – especially in warm weather– Fit isn’t always universal. – adjustments may not work well for every body or baby size and the term "ergonomic" can be misleading

Often more expensive – due to higher production costs and premium materials

Best for: Parents who want quick everyday use with added comfort and support for longer carries.

6. Hard Frame Carriers

Structured carriers with an internal metal frame, often used for hiking or outdoor adventures.

Pros:

Specialized support for long treks with bigger babies and toddlers.

Built-in storage for gear, snacks or diapers.

Designed for stability and ventilation.

Cons:

Heavy and bulky; not practical for everyday use.

Only suitable once the baby has good head and torso control.

Best for: Families looking for a special outdoor option.

7. Water Carriers

Carriers made from quick-drying, mesh or water-safe materials, designed for use in showers, pools, or at the beach.

Pros:

Lightweight and breathable.

Ideal for summer or water activities.

Easy to rinse and dry.

Cons:

Limited structure and support; not suitable for extended wear.

Typically used as a secondary carrier.

Best for: Parents wanting a backup carrier for beach trips, pools or hot climates.

8. Alternative Baby Carriers

While not part of the classic babywearing categories, these innovative or hybrid options offer unique benefits for specific situations:

Babywearing T-Shirts

Stretchy tops that double as newborn carriers, offering skin-to-skin contact and hands-free support.

Pros: Ideal for immediate postpartum bonding.

Cons: Limited support and lifespan - only suitable for the first few weeks.

Hippie Joey & Mumsie: Fashionable clothing pieces (ultra stretchy eternity loop and dungarees) with integrated sling-like panels for light babywearing.

Pros: Seamlessly combines style and function - great for quick cuddles on the go.

Cons: Less supportive and durable as a baby carrier, the fit and support vary based on body shape and baby size.

Trail Magik: A minimal seat-style carrier that attaches to a hiking backpack, allowing short carries during outdoor adventures.

Pros: Ultra-light and compact - perfect for trail use without hauling a full carrier.

Cons: Requires a compatible backpack and only works once your child is bigger and can sit upright independently.

Hip Seats / Hip Bolsters: Padded waistbands with a rigid “seat” platform for the child to rest on your hip. Some come with an optional soft panel for extra support.

Pros: Reduces strain on arms and back during frequent up-and-down moments with toddlers.

Cons: Bulky around the waist and not fully hands-free without additional support.

MiniMeis: Shoulder-mounted carrier where the child sits high on the parent’s shoulders, secured with a harness and foot straps.

Pros: Fun view for older babies and toddlers; good for short outings and travel.

Cons: Not suitable for infants; requires strong core and balance from the wearer; limited carry duration.

Vertical Carry Slings: (Unsupported Upright Carry in Tube-Style Slings)Some stretchy or looped slings on the market advertise upright front carry for newborns. Warning: These are generally not recommended - lack of structure and support poses a risk of asphyxiation due to baby's chin falling onto their chest.

Choosing the Right Carrier

The best baby carrier depends on your lifestyle, your baby’s age, and your personal comfort. Are you bying for yourself or you want to include your partner as well? A few tips:

*For newborns: Stretchy wraps or ring slings offer a snug, womb-like hold.

*For toddlers: Woven wraps, buckled carriers, or hard frame carriers offer necessary support.

*For warm climates: Look for breathable options like mei tais, onbuhimos or water carriers.

*For quick ups and downs: Ring slings or buckled carriers shine.

 *For your partner: chose a well adjustable design and a look you'll both enjoy.

Whenever possible, try carriers before buying. Local babywearing groups, consultants or lending libraries can offer personalized guidance and help you discover what truly fits.

Look Beyond the Labels!

Choosing a baby carrier isn’t just about picking what’s popular or well-marketed - it’s about finding what truly fits your body, your baby, and your lifestyle. With so many options available, it’s easy to be swayed by appealing product descriptions, glossy photos, or misleading labels like “ergonomic” or “from newborn.” But these can often give a false sense of security.

A poorly chosen or incorrectly fitted carrier can reduce both safety and comfort, leading to frustration instead of the joy and connection babywearing is meant to bring.

Take the time to explore your actual needs. Try different options if possible. Seek expert advice or visit a babywearing consultant or group. What works for one family may not work for another - and that’s okay.

Want to make babywearing simpler from day one? At babyloop, we’re on a mission to take the guesswork out of babywearing. Created by a certified babywearing consultant, babyloop is designed to adapt to your real life - without the trial and error. Want more tips (and first dibs on our carrier)? [Join our email crew]

Hi, I’m Michaela - certified babywearing consultant and founder of babyloop. My mission is to make babywearing simple, practical, and stress-free - from your very first carry to those toddler-on-your-hip days. Whether you're just starting out or want to carry with more confidence, I’ve got your back (literally).